UK Universities Reassess Turnitin Over AI Licence Row
A proposed Turnitin licence change on AI use of student work, now postponed to 2027, has pushed several UK universities to review or end their contracts.


A proposed change to Turnitin's licence terms has set off a wave of reviews at UK universities, with at least four institutions moving away from the plagiarism-detection service and others renegotiating. The dispute turns on whether a software supplier should be able to use students' submitted work to improve AI tools, and it shows how quickly routine contract language can become a flashpoint in education.
What Turnitin proposed and what has happened since
According to Times Higher Education, Turnitin proposed changes to its end-user licence agreement (EULA) covering AI processing of student submissions, originally set to take effect on 7 July 2026. Universities objected through UCISA, the membership body for university IT, and Turnitin has since postponed the changes to September 2027 and agreed to work with a UCISA representation group.
Student unions also objected. The Tab reports that unions at UEA, SOAS, St Andrews and York raised concerns, and that a Lancaster Tab poll found 95 per cent of respondents unhappy with the idea. On 29 September, it says, Turnitin stated it was redrafting the EULA and would not introduce a new one until 2027.
Turnitin maintains that it does not use student work to train generative AI or large language models and has no plans to do so. According to Times Higher Education (THE), the company instead trains a classifier that predicts whether text was written by AI. A commentary on Wonkhe adds that Turnitin says students keep ownership of their submissions and that any use would be in anonymised or de-identified form.
Which universities are moving
The responses differ in strength, and the reasons given are not identical.
Newcastle: Its education committee decided on a phased withdrawal, with no renewal beyond 2026-27. THE says its stated concern was licence terms that could allow staff and student data to be used for AI purposes from 2027.
Southampton: It announced earlier this year that it will end its relationship with Turnitin when its current deal lapses. Wonkhe reports it is switching to Blackboard's SafeAssign.
Westminster: THE says it will retire Turnitin when its contract ends in July 2027. Its stated reasons were confusion from running several submission systems and doubts about the tool's effectiveness against generative AI; THE says it did not mention data concerns.
Cambridge: THE says it will not accept EULA changes that affect data privacy or intellectual property, and continues to offer Turnitin for now. The Tab reports it was the first to refuse the new contract, in July, and is operating under a modified arrangement.
Aberystwyth, Aberdeen, Lancaster and Sussex: These are reviewing or hedging rather than leaving. Aberystwyth is under contract until July 2027 and lets uncomfortable students use Blackboard; Aberdeen is reviewing its use; Lancaster says it may review if terms change; Sussex still uses the tool as a similarity checker, as per Wonkhe.
The arguments underneath
The Wonkhe commentary argues that anonymisation answers a data-protection question, not a copyright one, since copying an essay into a training set is still copying. It also points out that Turnitin's denial covers generative AI and large language models while the original terms referred to AI tools more broadly, and that "no plans" is a statement of intent rather than a contractual guarantee. It adds that the existing agreement already grants a broad licence to student work for improving the services generally, and that consent is weak when use is mandatory for progression. These are the author's views, not established findings, and Turnitin disputes the underlying framing.
Not everyone reads the exodus as a data story. THE quotes Thomas Lancaster of Imperial College London arguing that cost is the main driver rather than AI concerns. The same report gives figures obtained from public records: Southampton paid £87,621 to Turnitin from 1 September 2024 to 30 September 2025, and UEA spent £50,892 from 1 April 2024 to 31 March 2025. Turnitin does not publish prices, which vary by institution. Phil Newton of Swansea University is quoted as saying most UK universities use only the originality checker, which does not detect AI text, so it is largely redundant, though he does not see cost as a major burden.
Christopher Lewis of Bucks New University, an Office for Students lead assessor, told THE that a full exodus has not happened yet but more universities are likely to reconsider, because virtual learning environments can already handle submission and feedback.
Why it matters beyond Turnitin
The episode is a case study in a wider tension. Educational software vendors increasingly build AI features, and improving them often requires data. Institutions that sign contracts on behalf of students, who rarely have a say, must decide how much licence over student work they are prepared to grant. Wonkhe notes that UC Berkeley said the AI provisions would not apply to its users because its contracts bar using institutional data with AI, which suggests that contract terms, not just vendor intentions, are what decide the outcome.
There is also a practical dimension. Westminster's reasoning, as reported by THE, was that AI detection is probabilistic and carries a risk of false positives. Where detection tools are being questioned on accuracy as well as data use, the case for keeping them as default infrastructure weakens, and the cost of switching falls if the learning platform already offers a submission tool. Westminster is moving its students to Blackboard Assignment from February 2027, according to The Tab.
What to watch next
The redraft is the main unknown. Wonkhe stresses that the changes are being rewritten, not dropped, and reports that Turnitin has told universities nothing will change before 1 September 2027. What the new text says about anonymisation, derived data and opt-out will decide whether the institutions that stayed remain comfortable.
Other open questions include whether more universities follow Newcastle and Southampton before then, whether regulators or sector bodies comment publicly (Wonkhe notes they have not so far), and whether students gain a formal role in the redrafting. Because accounts of individual universities' timelines differ slightly between outlets, anyone relying on a specific institution's plans should check its own statement.
For now, the dispute stands as an early test of how educational institutions will treat student work in an era when that work could be training material. The outcome will likely shape contract language well beyond one vendor.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did Turnitin propose?
A new end-user licence agreement covering AI processing of student submissions, originally set for 7 July 2026, according to Times Higher Education.
Has the change taken effect?
No. It has been postponed to September 2027 and Turnitin has agreed to work with a UCISA group on a redraft.
Does Turnitin say it trains AI on student essays?
Turnitin says it does not train generative AI or large language models on student work and has no plans to; THE says it trains a classifier that predicts whether text is AI-written.
Which universities are leaving?
Newcastle and Southampton plan to stop after 2026-27, and Westminster will retire it when its contract ends in July 2027; Cambridge is keeping a modified arrangement.
